The five demons that never arrived cover art

The five demons that never arrived

The five demons that never arrived

Listen for free

View show details

About this listen

The five demons that never arrived: The murder of Josh Bennett in Claremont, Illinois

A mother stabbed in the kitchen. A 20-year-old soldier about to be deployed to Iraq, killed in the chest by a curse that never existed. Two masked men convinced they were killing a pregnant teenage witch. The impossible contradiction: no one in the coven questioned that their spiritual leader - the "victim" of the curse - gave the orders for the assault.

In this episode, we explore how a Walmart employee manipulated adults to commit a murder disguised as a sacred ritual. The knife delivered as a "sacred tool," the candles with engraved names, the explicit instruction to "leave nothing in your path." And the truth that destroyed everything: Iria had dated Jackie, Jackie left her for Lindsay, and Iria invented the narrative of witchcraft out of jealousy disguised as witchcraft.

Victim: Josh Bennett
Date: August 23, 2005
Location: Claremont, Illinois
Status: Case solved, sentences executed

- The candle ritual took place at midnight on August 22; the assault began three hours later with ski masks and pepper spray.
- David, recruited as a "powerful wizard," was a criminal from St. Louis with a prior history of murder; Iria knew him.
- Rick attempted to stab the father of the house with pepper spray and accidentally inflicted a wound on his leg while trying to attack; he then fled to the cornfield.
- The declared target, Lindsay, escaped unharmed to the basement; Josh Bennett died accidentally in an operation built entirely on jealousy.

Josh Bennett, Claremont murder 2005, coven, cult manipulation, false curse, investigation, false serial killer, Iria Cotner, spiritual corruption, true crime Spanish

If you want to listen to this podcast ad-free and have access to premium episodes, we invite you to try our subscription with a 14-day free trial at obomedia.com.

© 2026 OBOMEDIA. All rights reserved.
This episode and its content (audio, text, and associated materials) are the exclusive property of OBOMEDIA and are protected by applicable copyright laws. Reproduction, distribution, editing, or commercial use in whole or in part is prohibited without prior written authorization from OBOMEDIA. For permissions, licenses, and business inquiries, write to: business@obomedia.com.

Recommended Listening:
If you are a fan of deep-dive investigative podcasts and suspenseful storytelling like Crime Junkie, True Crime with Kendall Rae, Dateline NBC, 48 Hours, Morbid, 20/20, Betrayal Season 5, MrBallen Podcast: Strange Dark & Mysterious Stories, My Favorite Murder, Criminal, Murder at the U, Snapped: Women Who Murder, Serialously with Annie Elise, Casefile True Crime, or The Epstein Files, this will be your new favorite podcast.

Topics Covered:
True crime podcast, unsolved mysteries, cold cases, serial killers, missing persons, real crime stories, investigative journalism, homicide investigations, forensic science, interrogations, 911 calls, true crime daily, true crime 24 hours podcast, unexplained deaths, true crime stories English.

This episode includes AI-generated content.
No reviews yet