Why Nuremberg Refused to Sentence Dönitz for Submarine Warfare — And What Fleet Admiral Nimitz's Sworn Testimony Reveals About America's Pacific War?

In this solo personal essay, Dale argues that the United States' unrestricted submarine campaign against Japan in World War Two was legally and morally identical to the German U-boat campaign for which Karl Dönitz was prosecuted at Nuremberg — and that the tribunal's own verdict, shaped by Fleet Admiral Chester Nimitz's sworn testimony, proves it. Fifty-two submarines lost. Over a thousand merchant ships sunk. One verdict that couldn't say what it meant.

https://discord.gg/dxSvauDb

On the night of August 1st, 1943, fifteen American PT boats entered Blackett Strait with thirty torpedoes and a solid intelligence picture. By morning, they had hit nothing, lost one boat, and left eleven men in the water. This is the story of that boat — and everything that happened before and after.

Dale and Christophe trace the full arc of PT-109: from her keel laid in Bayonne, New Jersey in March 1942, through the brutal Guadalcanal campaign, to the night a Japanese destroyer cut her in half in the dark. Along the way, they dig into the politics that put a medically disqualified young man from Boston in command, the engineering compromises baked into the Elco 80-footer, the catastrophic failure of the Mark 8 torpedo program, and what the Navy's own after-action record says — versus what John Kennedy said privately to a tentmate months later.

They also tell the stories that rarely get told: the crew members who died and deserve to be named, the two young Solomon Islander scouts who paddled 38 miles through enemy water with a coconut, and the coast watcher on a volcano who set the whole rescue in motion.

In the pre-dawn darkness of March 6, 1943, two veteran Japanese destroyers turned east into Kula Gulf after a routine supply run. They never knew what was waiting. Rear Admiral "Tip" Merrill had spent months building a doctrine around one radical premise: trust the radar completely. Four minutes after contact, he proved it worked — thirteen minutes later, 174 Japanese sailors were dead and two ships were on the bottom. No American casualties. No American damage. And almost no record. This is the first clean surface victory of the Solomons campaign — unnamed in the official histories, unknown to most Americans, and still one of the most instructive engagements the Pacific War produced. Also: the 71 men of USS Grampus, and why the strait that bears a dead British surveyor's name still matters.